Growth in IPv6 Capable DNS Infrastructure

Emile Aben — Mar 19, 2012 03:00 PM
Filed under: , , ,
We developed a script to measure IPv6 capabilities of DNS resolvers and clients two years ago. Recently we found some interesting trends in IPv6 capable DNS infrastructure.

In a recent post on RIPE Labs -  Networks with IPv6 - One Year Later - we showed encouraging growth in the number of IPv6 enabled networks. But announcing an IPv6 prefix is only one of the first steps a network operator should take. For a full IPv6 deployment, IPv6 has to be enabled on other key parts of the infrastructure and made available to end users. One key piece of infrastructure for which we can measure IPv6 capabilities, are DNS resolvers. These are typically (in roughly 80% of the cases) located in the same network as the end users who are using them. The big exceptions are end-users that use public DNS resolving services, like OpenDNS and Google Public DNS.

I've been tracking the IPv6 capabilities of the DNS resolvers that are used by visitors to www.ripe.net since early 2010. See Measuring IPv6 at Clients and Caching Resolvers for earlier results (March 2010). Two key metrics used here are the IPv6 preference of end users and the IPv6 capability of the DNS resolvers used by these end users. The IPv6 preference of end users measured here indicates the percentage of clients that connect over IPv6 to www.ripe.net, which is dual-stacked. The IPv6-capable resolvers measured here indicate the percentage of clients that use a DNS resolver that is capable of using IPv6 for DNS resolution (more details can be found in Measuring IPv6 at Clients and Caching Resolvers - Methodology). The intuition here is that network operators will first enable IPv6 on their caching DNS resolvers, and in later steps of IPv6 deployment roll it out to end users.

Recently I saw noticeable increases in IPv6 capabilities of DNS resolvers, as shown in the blue line in Figure 1. Note that the www.ripe.net-audience is biased towards network operators. That means the IPv6 capability of typical end-users is probably lower than what I measure here.

IPv6 capabilities of end-users and resolvers for www.ripe.netFigure 1: IPv6 in end-users and their DNS resolvers to www.ripe.net

As you can see, over 25% of end users that visit www.ripe.net currently use a resolver that is IPv6 capable. This is far more then the 2-3% of end users that really use IPv6 to visit www.ripe.net (as shown in the red line in Figure 1).

The gap between IPv6 capabilities of end users and the resolvers they use is widening over time. I think this is indicative of a frequently mentioned problem with deploying IPv6 to end-users: The lack of IPv6 capabilities in many (older) customer-premises equipment (CPE), and/or the economics of replacing old CPE. (See also the IPv6 CPE Survey on RIPE Labs). However, it does show operators extending the IPv6 capabilities of their networks, and why would they do that, other then to eventually provide this to their end-users?

Looking at the resolvers time series (blue line) in Figure 1 in more detail, there are two increases that jump out. One around November 2011 and one early March 2012. Table 1  shows the top 3 networks I see with IPv6 capable networks for a sample day each month since October 2011. As you can see, the increase around November can be attributed to Deutsche Telekom enabling more of their DNS resolvers to resolve over IPv6, and the increase in March is due to Google Public DNS. Note that the client-facing part of Google Public DNS has been accessible over IPv6 at least since June 2011, the change visible in Figure 1 is due to the DNS resolving part of this service being able to access DNS servers over IPv6. Both the October and March jumps show that big players are making progress on their IPv6 deployments.

Date Count IPv6 prefix Network Name
2011-10-08 93 2a01:e00::/32 Free.fr

70 2003:180::/32 Deutsche Telekom

70 2001:558::/32 Comcast
2011-11-08 619 2003:180::/32 Deutsche Telekom

144 2a01:e00::/32 Free.fr

136 2001:558::/32 Comcast
2011-12-08 538 2003:180::/32 Deutsche Telekom

149 2a01:e00::/32 Free.fr

146 2001:558::/32 Comcast
2012-01-08 514 2003:180::/32 Deutsche Telekom

132 2a01:e00::/32 Free.fr

126 2001:558::/32 Comcast
2012-02-08 606 2003:180::/32 Deutsche Telekom

177 2a01:e00::/32 Free.fr

176 2001:558::/32 Comcast
2012-03-08 2237 2a00:1450::/32 Google

557 2003:180::/32 Deutsche Telekom

157 2001:558::/32 Comcast

Table 1: Top 3 networks where we see IPv6 enabled caching resolvers for a sample day per month

Conclusion

We should not be overly optimistic about IPv6 deployment worldwide. There is a widening gap between IPv6-enabled DNS resolvers and end-users, and the real number of IPv6 enabled end-users is much lower then what we measure on www.ripe.net. This number is currently at around 0.4-0.5% according to measurements by APNIC that the RIPE NCC cooperates in and Google's measurements.

That being said, the Google measurements show encouraging growth. And both the IPv6-enabled networks and IPv6-enabled DNS resolvers growth curves as shown in the figure above, show broad progress towards full IPv6 adoption.

We're getting there ... slowly.

0 Comments

Add comment

You can add a comment by filling out the form below. Only plain text is possible. Web and email addresses will be transformed into clickable links. Comments are moderated so they won't appear immediately.

Navigation
Related Items
Increased Reach of RIPE Atlas Anchors

Increasing the reach of RIPE Atlas anchors is one of the highest priority goals of RIPE Atlas Team. ...

Proposing Making RIPE Atlas Data More Public

RIPE Atlas is now three years old, and is moving from a prototype to production service. Based on ...

Modifications to the IP Analyser to Reflect New Policy

We are in the process of implementing the policy regarding Post Depletion Adjustment of Procedures ...

Report on IPv6 Security Test Methodology

The Dutch Institute for Applied Scientific Research (TNO) and a number of Dutch security companies ...

RIPE Atlas: Improved Probe Pages

We've made it much easier to get an overview of the history and measurements for all the public ...

more ...