You are here: Home > Publications > RIPE Labs > Rene Wilhelm > Developments in IPv4 Transfers

Developments in IPv4 Transfers

Rene Wilhelm — 24 May 2016
In May 2015, we looked at IPv4 transfers in the RIPE NCC service region and found signs of an emerging market. Both the number and size of transfers conducted under RIPE Policy showed an upward trend in the years 2013-2014. One year later, we take another look. Did this trend continue? What have been the effects of the inter-RIR transfer policy?

Allocated PA and Assigned PI Space

Between 1 May 2015 and 1 May 2016, 7,374,080 addresses (about 44% of a /8) were transferred under the RIPE IPv4 transfer policies for allocated PA and assigned PI space. This is lower than the preceding 12 month period (May 2014 to May 2015) when 11,048,192 addresses (about 66% of a /8) were transferred. While the total number of transfers in the last 12 months has increased from 1,903 to 2,197, as Figure 1 demonstrates below, the general trend in this period is downward. The number of transfers conducted in April 2016 is less than a third of what was observed for June 2015.

 

Number and size of transfers on monthly basis, from Oct 2012 to May 2016

Figure 1: Number of IPv4 transfers and number of IPv4 addresses transferred in the RIPE NCC service region

 

As noted in our previous article , the number of transfers from 185/8 (the "last /8") started to increase in the fall of 2014. The majority of these transfers happened within a few months of the allocation being made. Because this was felt to be in conflict with the spirit of the allocation policy , members of the RIPE community made a proposal to prevent transfers for the first 24 months after receiving an allocation from the RIPE NCC. After much discussion, the policy proposal was accepted and implemented on 23 July 2015. The effects of the policy change are very visible in Figure 2, which shows the number of monthly transfers from 185/8. After a record number of 78 transfers in July 2015, the transfer rate of last /8 allocations came down hard in subsequent months. From 1 August 2015 to 1 May 2016, only 32 transfers were registered in this space, with an average age of the allocation (at time of transfer) of 25 months.

 

TransfersLastSlash8

Figure 2: Transfers from the last /8

 

Transfers per Country

To see how transfer activity is spread across the RIPE NCC service region, we aggregate the transfer data by country. For each transfer, we determine the originating and receiving country by locating the transferred block in the RIPE NCC delegation statistics archive before and after the date of transfer. For each country, transfers fall into one of three categories:

  1. Import: the transferred block originates in a different country
  2. Export: the transferred block is destined for another country
  3. Domestic: the transferred block stays within the country

The sum of all three is what we call "market size", a measure for the amount of addresses which changed  holder in each country over the last 12 months.

 

CartoDB map of transfers between May2015 and May2016

Figure 3: Geographic distribution of the last twelve months of IPv4 transfers

Figure 3, a screenshot of an interactive map , visualizes the results. The map colour-codes the countries by market size. The darker the colour, the more addresses were transferred to, from or within the country. Russia, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Romania, Germany, the Netherlands and the United Kingdom stand out as places with the most transfer activity between 1 May 2015 and 1 May 2016.

Looking at the details per country, shown in Table 1 below, we see different patterns in transfer activity. Russia saw about 1.9 million IPv4 addresses change holder; about two thirds (66%) of these were domestic transfers from one Russian organisation to another. In Iran, domestic transfers only account for 38% of the transferred addresses and Saudi Arabia relies almost exclusively on imports.

Just as last year, Romania is the top exporter, with 1 million transferred IPv4 addresses. However, not all of these addresses had been allocated to Romanian LIRs before. A closer look at the transfer statistics shows 393,216 of the transferred addresses were from 51/8; a block which until May 2015 was legacy space held by the UK's Department for Work And Pensions. What seems to have happened is that addresses were first transferred as legacy from the UK to Romania, after which the receiving LIR chose to have the legacy status of the transferred blocks removed before the addresses were transferred again, now with the status Allocated PA. Because the policies for transfers in the RIPE NCC service region do not apply to legacy resources, only the second transfer is listed in the transfer statistics, thus leaving an imbalance in Romania's aggregated statistics.

Country Imports Imported IPv4 Exports Exported IPv4 Domestic Transfers Domestic IPv4 Market Size
RU 11 6400 108 635136 268 1235968 1877504
RO 9 3072 386 1033728 627 437504 1474304
IR 113 823296 3 2304 32 497664 1323264
NL 62 421888 29 124672 44 244224 790784
DE 53 80896 54 421120 63 217344 719360
GB 80 115968 27 340992 51 184576 641536
SA 9 509952 0 0 1 2048 512000
ES 73 455168 10 10240 25 38656 504064
UA 7 20224 14 72960 56 229376 322560
TR 14 11008 2 16384 8 267520 294912

 
Table 1: Top ten countries by IPv4 transfer market size

 

Top Recipients and Originators

Aggregating the transfer data of the last 12 months by receiving or originating party shows which organisations have high demand for IPv4 and which are more happy to part with it. Table 2 lists the top ten recipients, ordered by total number of addresses transferred between 1 May 2015 and 1 May 2016. Four organisations, Mobile Communication Company of Iran, Saudi Telecom Company, Vodafone Espana and Superonline Iletsim Hitmetleri,  were also present in last year's top ten.

Liberty Global Operations B.V. is new in this top ten, with 327,680 addresses coming to the LIR via transfers. However, the transfer statistics reveal that the address blocks involved were transferred from UPC Austria GmbH and Virgin Media Limited respectively. Both entities are, like Liberty Global Operations B.V., subsidiaries of Liberty Global Plc. This illustrates how not all transfers in the allocated PA transfer statistics are necessarily the result of brokered transactions on the IPv4 market. Organisations holding multiple LIRs can also use the transfer policy to move IP addresses within the organisation or change how the addresses are administered.

 

Organisation Transferred IPv4 Addresses
Mobile Communication Company of Iran PLC 622592
Saudi Telecom Company JSC 393216
JSC "ER-Telecom Holding" 362752
Liberty Global Operations B.V. 327680
VODAFONE ESPANA S.A.U. 318464
"University Telecommunications" Ltd. 270848
"Rightel Communication Service Company PJS" 217088
Superonline Iletisim Hizmetleri A.S. 196608
Vodafone Libertel B.V. 172032
O2 Czech Republic, a.s. 163840

 
Table 2: Top ten recipients, ordered by size of transferred space

 

Table 3 lists the top ten organisations that originate transfers. As last year, Jump Management remains the top supplier, but they continue to cater to organisations with modest demands - 60% of their 144 transactions (transfers of one or more blocks to the same organisation on the same day) involve at most 2,048 IP addresses: a /21 or smaller.

Organisation

Transferred IPv4 Addresses
Jump Management SRL 555776
S.C. GVM SISTEM 2003 S.R.L. 458752
GOSTARESH-E-ERTEBATAT-E MABNA COMPANY (Private Joint Stock) 376832
Perspectiva Ltd. 360448
Link Telecom LLC 276480
State Institute of Information Technologies and Telecommunications 270848
ISP-Service AG 262144
IPv4 Management SRL 239872
Turkcell Iletisim Hizmetleri A.S 196608
Virgin Media Limited 196608


Table 3: Top ten originators, ordered by size of transferred space

 

Inter-RIR Transfers

On 30 September 2015, following successful implementation of " Policy for Inter-RIR Transfer of Internet Resources ", it became possible to transfer resources to other RIR service regions. Since then, we have recorded two transfers from the RIPE NCC to another RIR (a /22 and a /23, both transferred to ARIN) and 47 transfers from another RIR to the RIPE NCC. A closer look shows that several transfers took place on the same date with the same origin RIR and the same recipient organisation on the RIPE NCC side. Grouping these together, we find only 20 transactions in the inter-RIR transfer arena. In total, 2,497,280 IPv4 addresses have been transferred to the RIPE NCC service region. The largest part of these, 2,097,152 addresses (the equivalent of a /11) came to the RIPE NCC service region in a single transaction. On 28 December 2015, eight legacy /14s were transferred from ARIN to Softlayer's RIPE NCC LIR account. The next five largest recipients in terms of address space each had about a /16 of IPv4 space transferred to the RIPE NCC service region. Table 3 lists the top ten.

 

Organisation Transferred IPv4 addresses
SoftLayer Technologies, Inc. 2097152
RGnet, LLC 67072
SALAR LLC FZE 65536
A&F Networks B.V. 65536
Public Telecommunication Corporation 65536
SIEMENS AG 65536
INTER NET BILGISAYAR TURIZM TIC LTD STI 17664
TELE AG 16384
Awaser Oman LLC 8192
Sewan Communications S.A.S. 8192

 

Table 4: top ten organisations receiving address space via inter-RIR transfers to the RIPE NCC

Conclusion

In the second half of 2015 and the first half of 2016, both the number of transfers and the size of the transfers conducted under RIPE Policy started to show a downward trend. This is more likely a sign of fewer available addresses rather than decreasing demand for IPv4 addresses. Also, we have to stress that statistics for IPv4 transfers within the RIPE NCC service region only concern address space with the status Allocated PA or Assigned PI. Because legacy space is not subject to the RIPE transfer policies, the RIPE NCC cannot track or publish transfers in this area. Inter-RIR transfers are still too small in number to see any trend. In terms of the number of transferred IPv4 addresses, statistics are dominated by a single transaction, eight /14s transferred from ARIN to the RIPE NCC in December 2015.

1 Comment

Riccardo Gori says:
24 May, 2016 04:14 PM
Great analisys work!
thank you
Add comment

You can add a comment by filling out the form below. Only plain text is possible. Web and email addresses will be transformed into clickable links. Comments are moderated so they won't appear immediately.